The Top 10 places to be on Halloween on Long Island this year (2026)

Long Island, Halloween falls on a Saturday this year. That means a full weekend of costumes, DJs and late nights, and WLIT’s own DJs are leading the charge.

We dug through venue sites, ticket pages and local listings to build the list. Here are the 10 best places to party on Long Island for Halloween 2026, Nassau and Suffolk.

#1 Mulcahy’s Pub & Concert Hall, Wantagh

This is the one. Mulcahy’s calls it Long Island’s Biggest Halloween Party, and it’s the night the whole Island circles on the calendar. Headlining: WLIT’s own DJ Neil C and DJ Mike Savage.

Your ticket includes an open bar and buffet from 9 to 11 p.m., and there’s $2,000 in cash and prizes for the costume contest. Dajani, IN2UNE and Steve East B2B Dan Tanner hold it down in support.

Can’t wait until Saturday? Friday is 80’s vs 90’s Halloween with Decadia and Mike Savage, and the best costume wins a $200 Amazon gift card.

#2 Stereo Garden, Patchogue

The DJ Adoni Halloween Freak Show takes over Stereo Garden with a full DJ lineup. There is $2,500 in costume prizes on the line, plus bottle packages for your crew.

When / Where / Tickets: Sat., Oct. 24, 9 p.m. to 4 a.m. / 9 Railroad Ave., Patchogue / Eventbrite

#3 Blue Point Brewing Company, Patchogue

Let’s do the Time Warp again. Blue Point’s big Halloween party goes Rocky Horror this year, with live music, vendors and a costume contest.

When / Where / Tickets: Fri., Oct. 23, 7 p.m. to midnight / Blue Point Brewing, Patchogue / $25 on Eventbrite, includes first drink and a pint glass. 21+

#4 My Father’s Place, Roslyn

The Dead Dance Ball is a costume party built around haunted rock and nonstop dancing. Expect costume prizes and awards for the best moves on the floor.

When / Where / Tickets: Sat., Oct. 31, 8 to 10 p.m. / My Father’s Place at The Roslyn / $43 at mfpproductions.com

#5 Patchogue Halloween Bar Crawl, Patchogue

One wristband, a walkable Main Street route and Halloween drink specials at every stop. Patchogue in costume is a whole vibe.

When / Where / Tickets: Sat., Oct. 31 / Downtown Patchogue / pubcrawls.com. 21+

#6 The High Horse at Dark Horse Tavern, Farmingdale

The Long Island Pride Lions present The Witches Coven, a costume party with cocktails, dancing, raffles and a costume competition.

When / Where / Tickets: Fri., Oct. 23, 7 to 11 p.m. / The High Horse, Farmingdale / $35 on Eventbrite, includes appetizers. 21+

#7 The Suffolk, Riverhead

A Rocky Horror Picture Show night on Halloween itself, with the Zen Productions shadow cast, specialty cocktails and a costume contest.

When / Where / Tickets: Sat., Oct. 31, 8 p.m. and midnight / 118 E. Main St., Riverhead / $35, or $45 with a prop bag

#8 Bayville Scream Park, Bayville

Five haunted houses, themed restaurants and secret bars in one spot. Halloween weekend it stays open until 1 a.m.

When / Where / Tickets: Through Nov. 7 / Bayville / From $39.90 with fees, peak nights from $61.90

#9 Patchogue Theatre, Patchogue

The Rocky Horror Picture Show Original Cast Spooktacular Tour lands with the original Magenta, Patricia Quinn.

When / Where / Tickets: Thu., Oct. 29, 7:30 p.m. / Patchogue Theatre / patchoguetheatre.org

#10 Landmark on Main Street, Port Washington

Hocus Pocus: The Taste-A-Long Experience pairs the movie with themed treats timed to the big scenes. Easy date night before you hit the bars.

When / Where / Tickets: Fri., Oct. 30, 7 p.m. / Landmark on Main Street, Port Washington / landmarkonmainstreet.org

Whatever you’re wearing, Halloween weekend sounds better with WLIT. We’ll be talking Mulcahy’s and all things Halloween on air all month. Keep it locked to WLIT.FM.

Sources: Mulcahy’s, TicketWeb, Greater Long Island, Eventbrite (Stereo Garden), Eventbrite (Blue Point Brewing), My Father’s Place, Pubcrawls.com, Eventbrite (LI Pride Lions), The Suffolk, Bayville Scream Park, Patchogue Theatre, Taste-A-Long. Photo: Courtesy of Mulcahy’s.