Home/News & Events/Sports
Sports · Bellmore

Replay Sports Cards Bellmore opening date: grand opening is Saturday, Nov. 21

Replay Sports Cards opens its first Long Island shop at 2156 Bellmore Ave. with a grand opening Saturday, Nov. 21.

WLIT.FM NewsNov 6, 2026 · 2 min read
Rob Ansalone in front of the Replay Sports Cards logo wall

Bellmore, dig out the binders. The Replay Sports Cards Bellmore opening date is set: the grand opening is Saturday, Nov. 21, at 2156 Bellmore Ave.

It’s the national chain’s first shop on Long Island, and it’s run by a hometown guy. Rob Ansalone grew up hitting card shows with his dad, spent 15 years in insurance, and is now turning the hobby into his full-time job.

Quick facts
What
Replay Sports Cards, first Long Island location
Where
2156 Bellmore Ave., Bellmore
When
Grand opening Saturday, Nov. 21
What’s inside
Buy, sell, trade and grading. Sealed boxes, graded cards, high-end singles, plus $1 and $5 bins
Follow
@ReplayBellmore on Facebook and Instagram

Expect trade nights, team nights and birthday parties. The TVs will run live sports and stream card breaks from Replay’s Charlotte shop, and you can scan a QR code to buy into the live box openings.

Ansalone also wants to teach young collectors how to judge a card’s condition, look up its value and work a trade. And yes, he’d love for some athletes to stop by.

A Long Island story

Ansalone got back into cards during the pandemic, picking up LeBron, Kobe, Mahomes and Brady rookies. Now his son Dominic collects, and his youngest, Vincent, rips WWE packs. One of Replay’s founders, Mike Martin, is from Bellmore too.

His goal is simple. He wants Replay to be “the local spot that kids are excited to ride their bikes to.” Through Replay Gives Back, he plans to team up with youth leagues, PTAs and charities to get cards into more kids’ hands.

We’ll see you on the 21st. Keep it locked to WLIT.FM.

Source: Greater Long Island. Photo: via Greater Long Island.

More stories

All news →
WLIT.FM Non-StopLive from Long Island