Home/News & Events/Restaurants
Restaurants · Levittown

Plot twist: Vincenzo’s Pizzeria in Levittown is coming back

Vincenzo's served its 'last' slices on Halloween. Then the sale fell through, so the Levittown pizzeria is reopening.

WLIT.FM NewsNov 5, 2026 · 2 min read
Vincenzo's Pizzeria storefront on Wantagh Avenue in Levittown

Levittown, put the paper plates back out. Vincenzo’s is coming back.

The pizzeria on Wantagh Avenue served what was supposed to be its final pie on Halloween after eight years in the CVS shopping center. The shop had a buyer, a price and a Nov. 2 closing date. Then the buyers walked away.

Quick facts
What
Vincenzo’s Pizzeria is reopening after a planned sale fell through
Where
CVS shopping center on Wantagh Avenue, Levittown
When
Reopening date not announced yet
What’s new
Shop updates and new menu items

Owner Garret Klein broke the news on Facebook with a very Long Island line: “So, after further review… VINCENZO’S IS BACK.” He’s an Islanders fan, and he joked that the John Spano mess of the ’90s should have taught him not to celebrate a sale before it closes.

A Long Island story

When word got out that Vincenzo’s was closing, the regulars showed up with messages and visits. Klein said it reminded him how much the town means to him. He’s watched kids grow up, go off to college and start their lives, one dinner at a time.

Now he’s using the do-over to freshen up the shop and roll out new dishes he’s had in the works. Updates and the reopening date will come on the pizzeria’s Facebook page.

Your local slice spot survived. We’ll call that a win. Keep it locked to WLIT.FM.

Source: Greater Long Island. Photo: GLI/Andrew Rappaport, file.

More stories

All news →
WLIT.FM Non-StopLive from Long Island