Home/News & Events/Restaurants
Restaurants · Garden City South

A Brat Pack supper club from the family behind Emilio’s Ballato is open in Garden City South

Red velvet, Brat Pack photos and live music on weekends: Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club opened Oct. 27.

WLIT.FM NewsNov 18, 2026 · 2 min read
Chefs Salvatore Sorrentino and Anthony Vitolo pose fist to fist in a black leather booth at Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club

Garden City South, pull on the good jacket. There’s a supper club on Nassau Blvd. now.

Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club opened Oct. 27. Red velvet drapes, white tablecloths, crystal chandeliers, Brat Pack photos on the walls and live music on Friday and Saturday nights.

Quick facts
What
Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club, a 120-seat Italian American supper club
Where
9 Nassau Blvd., Garden City South (516-620-3945)
Opened
Oct. 27
Hours
Mon-Thu 5-10 p.m., Fri-Sat 4-11 p.m., Sun 3-9 p.m.
Live music
Friday and Saturday nights

Two chefs, one table

Chef Sal Sorrentino is back behind the stove in the same Garden City South space where he ran ITA Kitchen. He and his wife, Christina, left that partnership this summer and kept the lease.

His new partner is chef Anthony Vitolo. His family owns Emilio’s Ballato on Houston Street in Manhattan, the old-school spot Newsday says draws the likes of Taylor Swift, Rihanna and Billy Joel.

The two chefs were already fans of each other’s cooking. Two pop-up dinners in the old ITA room sealed the deal.

What to order

Newsday reports many of the dishes are off-menu favorites from Emilio’s Ballato. The ones to know: spicy paccheri with a hot Amatriciana sauce, braised beef-pork meatballs, and the veal Antonio, a fried chop for two topped with peas, crispy prosciutto, vodka sauce and mozzarella. Bringing the kids? There’s “Nonna’s pastina.”

“We are not looking for everything to go viral,” Sorrentino told Newsday. “We are just cooking authentic food.”

The club also does catering and private parties.

A Long Island story

A Little Italy legend’s recipes, a Long Island chef’s kitchen and a band on the weekend. That’s a Saturday night, Nassau style.

Tell us how your first dinner goes. Keep it locked to WLIT.FM.

Sources: Newsday, Long Island Times, Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club. Photo: Vitolo Sorrentino Italian Supper Club.

More stories

All news →
WLIT.FM Non-StopLive from Long Island