Home/News & Events/Restaurants
Restaurants · Levittown

Vincenzo’s Levittown reopening: the Wantagh Avenue pizzeria is back, with new heroes on the menu

Vincenzo's Pizza in Levittown reopened Nov. 18, just 18 days after closing, with a fresh look and new heroes on semolina.

WLIT.FM NewsNov 20, 2026 · 2 min read
Owner Garrett Klein and two others behind the counter at Vincenzo's Pizza in Levittown with a fresh pie

Levittown, your slice spot is back. Vincenzo’s Pizza reopened on Wantagh Avenue on Wednesday, Nov. 18, just 18 days after owner Garrett Klein served what he thought was his final slice.

Klein closed the shop on Halloween to spend more time at home with his son, who is almost a year old. Then the planned sale fell through. So he and his fiancée unlocked the doors, brightened the place up and got the ovens going again.

Quick facts
What
Vincenzo’s Pizza, reopened with a refreshed look and new menu items
Where
Wantagh Avenue, Levittown
When
Reopened Wednesday, Nov. 18
New on the menu
Chicken vodka burrata (hero or pasta entree), a Buffalo chicken hero, and every hero now on semolina bread

A Levittown story

When word got out that Vincenzo’s was closing, regulars lined up to say goodbye. Some of them have been coming in since they were little kids. Klein says he watched them grow up, and now they are getting ready to graduate.

Now the next chapter is his son growing up around those same faces. Klein is also working on new pies, some inspired by friends and some by takes he has spotted on social media.

Long Island takes two things very seriously: its pizza and its local spots. This one gets both. Grab a slice, turn up the radio and keep it locked to WLIT.FM.

Source: Greater Long Island. Photo: GLI/Andrew Rappaport.

More stories

All news →
WLIT.FM Non-StopLive from Long Island